Sunday, 23 January 2011

Leadership



Leadership, although having several similar traits to management, is essentially very different. Leadership is described by Stacey (1996) as being as ‘transferring directives of those higher up in the hierarchy into the goals and tasks of the group.’ Leaders are present to create ideas; to build and motivate a ‘cohesive team’ {Stacey 1996}, in order to perform tasks effectively and efficiently. A natural born leader is insinuated as possessing the traits to inspire and instigate passion within his peers.
Management on the other hand, is seen as very much formal, consisting of ‘formal administrative bureaucracy.’ The manager’s job is primarily to plan, control, organise and, in turn, to achieve results. As a result, managers are seen as more impersonal and less emotionally involved; where a leader requires to be able to understand and interpet his peers on an emotional level, no such skills are required in management, which is primarily autocratic.
The variance in leadership styles has been developed through many different theories, one of which being Blake and Mouton’s ‘Managerial Grid.’ (1964).

As shown in the grid above, Blake and Mouton suggest that there are five main types of leaders: ‘Impoverished,’ ‘Country club’ (social), Authoritarian,’ ‘Middle of the Road’ and ‘Team leader.’
 According to Mullins (2010), the impoverished manager has low concern for both production and people and tend to be remote from both. The idea with this leadership style is that too much attention to production will cause difficulties with staff and vice versa.
In turn, the country club manager is said to have low concern for production and high concern for people. Such managers believe that ‘a contented staff will undertake what is required of them and achieve a reasonable level of output,’ (Mullins 2010). However, this means production is second to avoidance of conflict and maintaining a content staff, which may mean organisational output suffers as a result. Alternatively, the authoritarian manager has a high concern for production and low concern for people and tends to ‘rely on a centralised system’ (Mullins 2010), and the use of authority. Staff are regarded as a means of production and is motivated through competition amongst them in order to get the job done.
The middle-of-the-road management style refers to managers who have moderate concern for both staff and production. According to Mullins (2010), such managers are usually referred to as ‘dampened pendulums,’ with them swinging between concern for production and concern for people, dependant on the pressure they are put under.
Finally, the highest rated style of management refers to team managers, who, as a result of having high concern for both production and people, combine and integrate task needs with the needs of staff, therefore managing both tasks and employees efficiently.
To apply the theory behind the Blake-Mouton managerial grid practically, I have chosen to use the scenario of the team leader I worked under as part of an advertising sales team for a local newspaper. Due to the fact that the team leader continually alternated from prioritising the task OF ensuring maximum advertising space was sold for maximum price, to the needs of staff, dependant on the pressure to address each, the leader’s management style was relatable to that of a middle-of-the-road manager. This is as a result of the fact that although at times the team leader would entirely focus on the task at hand, she would then alternate to focusing on staff concerns, regardless of production, such as general staff difficulties in meeting sales targets meaning the targets had to be lowered, irrespective of the affect to sales figures.
In general, however, there are many well-known figures which epitomise good leadership. One such person I feel shows strong leadership qualities is Martin Luther king, the American civil rights campaigner for black people. King, in my opinion, effectively characterised aforementioned traits of good leadership. One such skill is inspiring and instigating passion within your peers, which King was known for, proven through the fact that his campaign was the major cornerstone in improving the rights of black people in America. King effectively conveyed his message in a way that inspired people to understand and act upon his way of thinking. This shows his method of leadership is directly relatable to Stacey’s (1996) theory on leadership, as King effectively ‘took’ directives and turned them into ‘goals and aims,’ which he achieved through instigating passion within his peers.
Conclusively, my research on leadership has shown me that there are major differences between leaders and managers, with distinct qualities defining each. Whilst the latter is usually impersonal and autocratic, focused on organisation, plan and control, the former is more concerned with personally directing and inspiring people, and the best leaders are able to do so to the extent of bringing out the best in their peers in terms of output and achievement.

References:

Sunday, 9 January 2011

Organisational Culture

Organisational culture is defined by Mullins (2010) as the ‘collection of values, policies, beliefs and attitudes’ that illustrates a universal and general context for everything we think and do within an organisation.
The organisation I have chosen in order to exemplify the idea of organisational culture is the retailer John Lewis. The company is famous for its dedication to customer service, and its staff and work policies are tailored to create the best service possible for customers. As a result, staff at John Lewis is trained to be polite, friendly and well-mannered, and employees are instructed to go out of their way in dealing with customer enquiries. One example of this is the employees on the shop-floor dedicated to checking on the welfare of customers and aiding them in their purchases, not only illustrating John Lewis’s dedication to its customer service, but the strong ‘people’ culture it employs, where staff are very much hands on with customers.
In addition to customer service, John Lewis strives to create a formal and professional environment reflective of the expensive and high quality nature of the products in its department stores. As such, employees are always dressed in formal attire, and company policy dictates that they be well-groomed in appearance at all time, in order to reflect the nature of the stores. This again ties in with company policy of staff being well-spoken and polite, as John Lewis aims to look both professional and reputable, maintaining its primary aim of good customer satisfaction.
The formal nature of the culture within John Lewis is further emphasised through the structure of the organisation, which primarily consists of a rigid hierarchical structure from management at the top of the organisation to bottom-tier employees. For example, shop floor attendants report directly to department managers and so forth. This illustrates the formal and autocratic nature of the organisation, which aids John Lewis in maintaining high professional standards reflective of their brand.
However, the formal presentation of staff and structure of the company contrasts to the engaging and light-hearted way in which staff interact with one another and customers. As all staff members are ‘partners’ of John Lewis, there is a culture of equality amongst employees, encouraged by John Lewis, which motivates staff and propels them to be more enthusiastic and interested in the organisation’s operations. John Lewis primarily believes in the theory that happy staff will translate into happy customers.
Conclusively, the cultural aspects of equality amongst staff, formal presentation, and also the company’s dedication to good and strong customer service and relations is exemplified within the video below.

In general terms, there are various ways in which organisational culture can be categorised. The most well-known theory of types of culture, however, is that of Charles Handy.  Each of Hardy’s proposed culture types is said to have stemmed ‘from a different presupposition about human motivation, thought and learning,’ (Work.com), and each is said to assume a different basis for power and influence within the organisation. The four types Hardy suggested were the cultures of Power, Role, Task and Person.
A Power culture is defined as an organisation where decisions are ‘centralised around one key individual’ or power source (Learnmanagement2.com). Power cultures are usually found in small or medium-sized businesses, where control is had by one individual or source, and thus there are few rules and procedures. An example of organisations utilising such a culture could be small corner shops and off-licences, where operational decisions are made through one key individual, likely the owner, and there are no formal procedures or guidelines, due to the informal nature of the business.
A Role culture entails working by ‘logic and rationality’ (Mullins 2010) and is often seen as a bureaucracy. In depth, a role culture involves organisations being ‘split into various functions, and each individual within the function… assigned a particular role.’ (Learnmanagement2.com). The benefit of this type of culture is specialisation, where employees focus on their particular job roles assigned to them, thus increasing productivity. As this is a logical and simple structure to use most formal organisations adopt some semblance of this culture. For example, the technology company Microsoft is likely to have set departments within its organisation, whereby staff are given specific job roles, e.g. software developers to write and test new software, and recruitment personnel tasked with hiring and firing staff.
Alternatively, a Task culture is job or project oriented and refers to a ‘team-based approach to complete a particular task,’ (Learnmangement2.com). Such a culture allows ‘flexibility [and] adaptability,’ (Work.com), due to the team-based approach of the culture, where ideas and expertise comes together collectively, rather than through one individual. Such culture can also be present within a multitude of organisations such as, for example, the software company Sage, whereby new software projects are taken on and developed in teams with tasks allocated within the group to those best suited to completing them.
The final culture theorised by Hardy is a Person culture, whereby the individual is the ‘central focus, and any structure exists to serve the individuals within it.’ (Mullins 2010).  According to thetimes100.co.uk, this form of culture exists when individuals are allowed fully to express themselves and make their own decisions. An example of this could be a professional such as a fashion or interior designer, where the structure of the business exists solely to aid them and the end product is directly a result of their vision and creativity.
The main problem with classifying organisations using the culture types above is that some companies, especially larger ones with separate departments and a large number of employees, do not comply rigidly with any one culture. Most organisations tend to use a multitude of the culture types stated, and various types may be found in different aspects of the business. For example, a company like Apple could be said to have a person culture due to the head of the company Steve Jobs, who possesses the vision and creativity to delve into new technological concepts and is seen by most as the mastermind behind new ideas. However, the technology development departments of the businesses would employ a task culture, whereby employees work in teams to create and develop a single product.
Conclusively, I feel that although there is reason to conclude that there are different types of cultures which organisations employ, the evidence states that not all organisations conform rigidly to one specific type, and instead are likely to use a mixture of culture types for different aspects of the business.

References:
Dininni, J. [n.d] Guide to Management Theory of Charles Handy [online]. Available from: http://www.work.com/management-theory-of-charles-handy-10990/ [Accesed 28 December 2010]
Learnmanagement2 Team [n.d] Organisational Culture [online]. Available from: http://www.learnmanagement2.com/culture.htm [Accessed 28 December 2010]
Mullins, L J. (2010) Management and Organisational Behaviour. 9th ed. Essex: Pearson
The Times 100 [n.d] Corporate and Organisational Culture [online]. Available from: http://www.thetimes100.co.uk/theory/theory--corporate-organisational-culture--322.php [Accessed 09 January 2011]
Bibliography:
Beck, R C. (2004) Motivation Theories and Principles. 5th ed. New Jersey: Pearson Education
CIPD [n.d] Vision and values: organisational culture and values as a source of competitive advantage [online]. Available from: http://www.cipd.co.uk/research/_visionandvalues.htm [Accessed 28 December 2010]

Monday, 22 November 2010

Motivation- Improving Staff Performance

Further to the previous blog exploring what motivation actually is, this topic can be further expanded upon by examining the many theories written on motivation. These theories can be separated into two groups: Concept Theories and Process Theories.
Concept theories are primarily based on attempting to explain the specific things that motivate individuals within the work place. Such theories identify ‘people’s needs and their relative strengths, and the goals they pursue in order to satisfy these needs,’ (Mullins, 2010 p.260). Process theories, conversely, are focused on identifying the variables that make-up motivation in terms of a ‘rational cognitive process,’ illustrating the relationship between said variables, (changingminds.org). Therefore, these theories primarily look at how an individual’s behaviour is ‘initiated, directed and sustained,’ (Mullins p.260), in terms of motivation.
The primary difference between Concept and Process theories is that the former are focused on emphasising the nature of personal needs and, particularly, it what is that motivates people, whereas Process theories concern the actual process of motivation.
To further understand the theory behind motivation, I have chosen to research staff motivation undertaken by the company Lloyds TSB. Lloyds state within their company aims that their focus is on providing motivation to individuals based on personal needs: “We’re all different, and our needs change over time. So, a school leaver has different needs to new parents, who have different needs to people without children,” (lloydstsbjobs.com). Lloyds therefore operates a reward scheme called 'Flavours,' in order to cater to all various motivational needs.This shows their understanding of the principles of Concept theories, and the differentiation of the nature of personal needs between individuals.
Lloyds employ many different methods of motivating their employees, the foremost being added cash incentives and bonuses on top of employee salaries, to motivate them in performing effectively within their job roles. One method of providing employees with bonuses is defined as a ‘flexible benefits cash sum (4% of salary) which is added to your pay and which you can 'invest' in the benefits you want - or to take as cash.’ Employees are further allowed to exchange job perks, such as vacation days, for cash sums. The incentive of money is further enforced by the company’s promise to contribute to employee pension funds ‘over and above’ their own, motivating employees with security after retirement.
In turn, Lloyds further provide ‘discounted offers’ on their own products and also holidays, car hire and health clubs. This along with options for private dental and health care for employees and their families, allows the company to provide staff with financial security along with satisfaction of basic needs such as health, further enforced through the provision of ‘life assurance, critical illness… and personal accident insurance’ cover, in order to motivate staff to perform their jobs to the best of their abilities.
Lloyds also motivate their employees through the use of flexible working, to help ‘strike the right balance between work-life and home.’ Allowing staff to work at hours more suitable for them encourages them to fulfil their job roles with more efficiency and focus, as they are more motivated to complete the tasks at hand at times more suitable for them.
Analysing these provisions from a critical point of view, many of Lloyd’s choice of motivational techniques seem to be in line with Expectancy theories of motivation, particularly that of Porter and Lawler. Mullins (2010) illustrates that Expectancy theories focus on the relationship between ‘effort expected and perceived level of performance,’ and the expectation that reward is related to performance. Porter and Lawler portrayed this idea through the following motivation model:

Porter and Lawler insinuate that individuals make choices/decisions about their behaviour and act rationally in that process, and that their level of effort and drive is unique to them. Thus, the model above, in short, depicts that the level of effort is directly relational to work performance, which in turn is proportional to the level of reward received, and such ideas can be readily attributed to Lloyd’s motivation methods.
The main motivational technique Lloyds employs that is in line with this process theory is the use of cash incentives and bonuses for good work. This motivates the employees in terms of the fact that they are likely to increase effort within their daily roles in order to receive such incentives. This means that they are likely to increase the quality of their performance, which in turn reaches the end result of them receiving rewards for their efforts in the form of cash sums. This motivation chain of effort relating to performance, and in turn relating to reward, is an exact illustration of the ideas conveyed Porter and Lawler’s motivation model.
Alternatively, it could be argued that the rest of Lloyds TSB’s motivational methods do not satisfactorily relate to this process theory. This is due to the fact that the remainder of the motivational benefits the company provides are not dependant on performance, but on a person merely being an employee of Lloyd’s, such as the free dental care and discounts. This means that staff may not perform at their best because, as is expressed within Porter and Lawler’s Expectancy model, there is no reward for increased effort- the motivational perks are provided so long as the employees have their jobs. Thus, this could have the effect of employees only doing the bare minimum required to keep their jobs and enjoy company benefits, and shows Lloyds TSB is not utilising the Expectancy theory as productively as it could be.
Conclusively, my research has shown me that the level of motivation within an organisation has a direct impact on staff performance, and various methods, in the form of process theories can be utilised to increase staff performance, such as in the case of Lloyds TSB. However, failure to utilise such methods effectively can result in lack of motivation and staff not performing as productively as they could be, which is detrimental to a company’s operations, and has shown me the value of improving and enhancing motivation to improve the performance of staff within an organisation.


References,
Mullins, Laurie J. (2010) Management and Organisational Behaviour. 9th ed. Essex: Pearson
ChangingMinds.org [n.d] Motivation [online]. Available from: http://changingminds.org/explanations/motivation/motivation.htm [Accessed 29 October 2010]
Lloydstsbjobs.com [n.d] Rewarding you [online]. Available from: http://www.lloydstsbjobs.com/rewarding-you.asp [Accessed 29 October 2010]
Lloydstsbjobs.com [n.d] Flavours [online]. Available from: http://www.lloydstsbjobs.com/flavours.asp [Accessed 29 October 2010]

Monday, 11 October 2010

Motivation

Motivation
Motivation is the internal desire humans have to fulfil instinctive needs, and is a utensil required in everyday life in order to achieve personal goals and aspirations.  It is described as consisting of ‘internal and external factors that stimulate energy in people to apply continuous and consistent effort in attaining a goal.’ (Businessdictionary.com).
Motivation can be analysed in many different ways and has inspired various theories which are dedicated to evaluating it. The theory that I feel is most relevant to myself is Abraham Maslow’s concept of the hierarchy of needs. The principles of this theory entail a person having a hierarchy of needs they wish to fulfil, where motivation is based on wishing to accomplish the next level of need once the requirements of the previous level have been satisfied. The idea is also put forward that higher levels cannot be fulfilled until lower levels of needs are met. As stated in Management and Organisational Behaviour, Maslow’s basic preposition is that people are wanting beings, and what they want depends on what they already have. (Mullins, 2007 p.260), thus justifying the hierarchy of needs.

The above diagram illustrates the various levels of need which Maslow believed all people aspire to. Physiological needs are basic wants such as food and shelter, and Maslow’s theory suggests that the higher levels of safety and social needs cannot be met until this is acquired. However, this level of need illustrates how subjective the hierarchy can be. For example, the need for food and shelter is very easily met in a first world country such as Great Britain, which therefore reduces the significance of this level of need within the hierarchy. However, a person within a poverty-stricken country is more likely to aspire to the physiological level of need.
In turn, once this level of need is met, the theory suggests a person will aspire to fulfil Safety needs. This, in terms of a corporate environment, for example, could refer to an employee’s want of job security in order to ensure they have a consistent means of income. A person will not be able to aspire to the next level of Social needs until such issues have been resolved, as they will not be deemed to be at the same level of importance. However, once Safety needs have been met, Maslow suggests a person will aspire to fulfilling Social needs. Such needs depict a personal desire for interaction, e.g. to be part of a group, for instance, where they can emotional wants can be met with like-minded individuals. Such a sense of belonging is likely to boost an individual’s confidence, whereby they look to enhancing their self-esteem.  Within this level of need, a person will want recognition and to further their achievements to give them a sense of self accomplishment. This need for self-respect involves the desire for confidence, independence and freedom, (Mullins, 2007). Henceforth, such a level of confidence motivates people to seek Self-Actualisation, where they can develop to their full potential. Here they are suggested to be finally content, for example, in terms of job satisfaction. They have reached the point where they have achieved everything they are capable of achieving, as the theory portrays the fact that once a person has fulfilled a lower need, achieving it motivates them no longer. Thus, ‘a satisfied need is no longer a motivator.’ (Maslow 1943).
My personal motivation for starting my degree course stems from the need I have to prove myself academically. I feel that achievement at the highest place of education will allow me to do this, as the opportunity I have for independent learning and self-reliance mean that the credit I could get in managing to achieve academically will be all the more rewarding. In turn, these wants are also what will motivate me for the next three years, as it will be my desire to gain a good grade at the end of my degree that will drive me to work hard within my course. For these reasons, I feel my desires relate to the Self Esteem level of need within Maslow’s hierarchy, as I am looking to gain achievement and recognition through my degree. However, I also feel that the fact that my desires are more relatable to the Self Esteem level of need brings up the question of how reputable Maslow’s hierarchy is in terms of the order of needs. As a new student, I feel that I have not yet managed to satisfy social or safety requirements, due to the university and my peers still being relatively unknown to me. This means that I have therefore not conformed to Maslow’s order of needs or his theory that progression to the next level of need can only occur once the previous one has been fulfilled.
On a different note, this previous summer I received my A level results, and was dismayed to find out that I hadn’t done as well as I’d hoped within my Maths A level. In contrast to me being highly motivated to achieve academically, failing to do so was a high de-motivator, as I had failed to achieve satisfy my requirements for needs of Self Esteem, as present in Maslow’s hierarchy. This caused me to drop down to the Safety level of need, as I was worried my grade would damage my prospects of employment. However, as de-motivated I was in terms of finding a job, I was also partially frustrated on the Self Esteem level that I hadn’t managed to do myself justice and perform to my full capabilities. This had the contrasting effect of driving me to view my goal of doing well within my degree with even more focus and determination, which means that I may still be categorised as aspiring to fulfil the Self Esteem level of need within Maslow’s Hierarchy, as my failing has motivated me to do better academically within my degree, in order to prove my capabilities.
Conclusively, I feel that although Maslow’s theory is largely correct, the rigid order the needs are placed in do not reflect, in my opinion, how needs are categorised by people in real life, where personal desire is influenced by individual and personal motivators. However, analysing my experiences against Maslow’s theory has allowed me to understand the workings and value of motivation as a tool and how it is utilised to achieve desired goals.

References,
Mullins, Laurie J. (2010) Management and Organisational Behaviour. 9th ed. Essex: Pearson
BusinessDictionary team, Motivation definition [online]. Businessdictionary.com. Available from: http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/motivation.html [Accessed 10 October 2010].
Maslow, A. H. (1943). A Theory of Human Motivation. Psychological Review 50, 370-96